Cable Discussion > General Cable Discussion

Marks out of ten for each track off the new Cable tribute album

<< < (10/20) > >>

Martin:
If you guys how shit the rest of In Flights songs are you'd appreciate just how good their covewr is.

Some of you're opinions are really negative, I know Rob personally, I used to be in a band with the guy, I know he would have made the best job possible with what he had to work with. They were told oringinally that they had to keep the same structure contractually, you should really direct your crtitcisms at Mr Signature Tune for not getting the plan straight legally before asking bands to do covers.

The IFP cover is fucking ACE and when I heard it in DubRek, the studio where it was recorded I was totally blown away. Hey, it might be the same, at least it is totally rocking though!! I've seen IFP program develope, I've been at many gig where I've nearly fallen asleep but now I think they are finally begginning to hit the spot. Don't shoot them down, you know what the constraints were when they recorded the song, so the next oerson to say it sounds a bit too much like the original is a fucking idiot!

As for Tellison, I think it sounds like they have murdered a fairly cherpy up beat song. Each to their own!

Keep up the good work...

Well done to Signature Tune for releasing the album too....

Corporate_Automaton:
Ahoy!

Mmmm. I'm not so sure about the Tellison cover.  Like Martin said, its lost a lot of the up-beat-ness (is that a word?) and what was a pretty cheery song is now kinda depressing!  I can't get stupid myspace to play the whole song, though - it keeps crashing after about a minute so maybe when it gets going it's a bit cheerier?

Fair play to all the bands who've had a go at doing a cover, though.  Especially those brave enough to try and do something new with the song as you run the risk of upsetting a lot of Cable fans!


--- Quote from: Martin on September 11, 2006, 05:52:03 pm ---Well done to Signature Tune for releasing the album too....

--- End quote ---
Yep, I totally agree.

Thanks,

Corporate_Automaton

Damon:
I have to say that the Song 1 cover is my favourite so far, more like this please!!!!

Damon

PlacidCasual:
Wasnt what i was expecting I like the tellison cover, or at least its not bad, it is quite downbeat but the vocals are good and it grew on me more after a second listen. I give it 7/10.

Re Martin - to say some of our comments are negative and that we are idiots for not liking the  IFP cover is a bit rediculous dude. Id only be lying if i said i thought it was good, i think some people have taken it too much to heart and cant accept that not everone likes it.

Damon:
Martin behaviour like that is NOT tolerated in this forum, if I have to I will ban you and remove your posts. No one has said anything about the band, only what they think of the cover song. Everyone (like myself) knows that when they are part of a band they put themselves up for criticism, I myself didn?t like the cover simply because it sounds too much like the original but that is my opinion and why this thread was started.

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and no one is right or wrong but this forum is not about insulting everyone as you don?t like what they have to say.

Damon

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page